By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more

Which Low Wing Trainer??

All Topics | Latest Posts

Search for:  in Thread Title in  
Chris gregg07/11/2016 18:53:42
53 forum posts

hello,

With Christmas round the corner and me progressively learning to fly my eflite apprentice on advance mode come January i will be looking at getting a new plane, i am new to building planes so would like a low wing IC plane to advance to from my apprentice.

My question is when what plane is most forgiving and ''easier'' to handle? also i would like a plane that doesn't have to much assembly required as its my first ic model.

I do have specktum dx6 that i can use also would just need to buy the reciever to go into the plane.

ChrisB07/11/2016 19:09:19
1220 forum posts
34 photos

For your first IC model I'd recommend something like the Black Horse Travel Air or Super Air or the Seagull 40.

They are all suitable for 40-50 size engines, something like an Irvine 46 or ASP 52.

You'll have to install your chosen engine and fuel tank, servos, receiver, battery and switch.

Fit the UC, glue the tail on and glue the wing halves together, glue and pin the control surfaces and set up the control throws, directions and centre of gravity.

A weekends work will see it done. The bits that take the longest are gluing the wing halves together and gluing the tail on..mostly waiting for the glue to dry. I use 1hr or 24hr epoxy.

Cheers

Denis Watkins07/11/2016 19:12:26
4656 forum posts
132 photos

I would seriously consider an IC Trainer 1st Chris to take you forward, usually they have more weight and inertia to deal with. Look up 2 Seagull models, the Swinger 25 and the Boomerang 46, And the Wot 4 IC. The ultimate choice is yours.

Former Member07/11/2016 19:35:13
3573 forum posts

[This posting has been removed]

Chris gregg07/11/2016 19:43:06
53 forum posts

i understand the reason for a high wing trainer at 1st, better than a broken plane!

i just though with having experience with a high wing apprentice i could move to low wing, but it seems from you guys flying a high wing IC to electric high wing is completly different??

If thats the case i guess i should go with the high wing i just dont want to out grow the high wing to soon if you get me

thanks for all your replies

chris

rcaddict07/11/2016 20:11:06
531 forum posts
2 photos

get a wot 4 artf - you will never outgrow it - and you can have IC or EP

Denis Watkins07/11/2016 20:12:15
4656 forum posts
132 photos

Chris, you could do your "B" Certificate with a Boomerang, but that is not important. With a foamy trainer you can "get a moment" to collect your thoughts, during a flight, they do fly well when trimmed out. With the extra weight and inertia of IC and Large Electrics, there are fewer moments to "change your mind" in flight. It is difficult to put into words, but learn to fly IC like you did your 1st electric, and you have the advantage now as you know the "sticks" better. Get to know your IC and keep an eye on the low wingers for future. The Travel Air and Speed Air are strong low wing models to move onto.

ChrisB07/11/2016 22:17:38
1220 forum posts
34 photos

As others have said.

High wingers worth having are Seagull Boomerang and Wot 4

Jon - Laser Engines07/11/2016 22:35:56
5678 forum posts
273 photos

I agree with the guys suggesting you go for a high wing ic trainer. Compared to the apprentice any IC model will be like a brick and when it comes to landing you need to completely change your landing speed etc.

Its not a difficult change, but it will come as a shock to the system as landing speeds will be double or perhaps triple what the apprentice is capable of

ChrisB07/11/2016 22:42:19
1220 forum posts
34 photos
Are you in a club Chris? As there will be members who can help you with setup and flying.
Chris gregg07/11/2016 23:06:39
53 forum posts
yes im going to be joing smithy mac in handforth manchester, im meeting fellow member tim on friday to take my apprentice for a fly and hes very kindly said i can buddy up on his boomerang!!

glad i know i got aloy of good advice off you guys whilst starting up

Edited By Chris gregg on 07/11/2016 23:07:05

Philflyer07/11/2016 23:26:42
avatar
113 forum posts
74 photos

Hi Chris. Before you decide, have a look at this thread

ARTF Seagull 40 Low wing Trainer.

I've had 2 Boomerangs and they are great. However my 2nd one is now just about worn out but I will not buy another high winger. As others have said here the Boomerang will do just about everything including the B schedule, so what's the problem? The main reason is they are a handful in strong crosswinds and here in South Wales that seems to be the norm.. The good thing about a heavier ic engined model is you can fly in just about any wind less than 15 knots and when you get bit more experienced you will want to push the boundaries. Landing well in a good crosswind gives you a great feeling but that all disappears if the wind gets under the wing and upsets it just when you think you are safely down - and it will. Also inverted flying is harder with a high winger with any amount of dihedral. They are naturally unstable when upside down. Have a look at the thread. Everyone says the Seagull 40 is stable and a great flier. I think it could make the next step for you if you feel you have outgrown the Apprentice. Yes the landing speed will be higher but it will be with a Boomerang anyway. The key factor is can you handle your aircraft well in the roll axis. That is the main difference between a stable high winger and a low winger. The high wing with dihedral has built in roll stability. Even so the Seagull 40 also has dihedral so still has some stability. It will not correct itself if you get in trouble and let go of the sticks hoping it will sort itself out, but the Boomerang won't either. None of us on this forum know how well you handle your present airframe so we are all guessing, and a high wing trainer is the safest advice. It may also be a waste of hard earned cash. You are going to make up your own mind no matter what we say here so take look at all the options and let us know how you get on.

IanN07/11/2016 23:40:33
avatar
1675 forum posts
119 photos
Posted by ChrisB on 07/11/2016 19:09:19:

For your first IC model I'd recommend something like the Black Horse Travel Air or Super Air or the Seagull 40.

+1 for the Super Air.

Slightly bigger than the Seagull 40. Nice big wing and has a wide performance envelope. it was the model I felt most comfortable with when transitioning from my trainer, and will do all you want as you progress.

You say you're joining a club. In that case I'd suggest skipping the high wing i.c. trainer and going straight down the low wing route, but via a buddy box for your first few flights - I guess when you've had that buddy session on the Boomerang you'll know for yourself which is the right route for you

Jon - Laser Engines08/11/2016 08:46:57
5678 forum posts
273 photos

I wouldnt recommend the super air. Its a great model but the undercarriage are mounted to the wings and if you land heavy you can do major damage to the wings. Once proficient with IC models it would be a good choice though. The Travel air is better in this regard but i have already tried to transition one 'customer' from electric foamy (st discovery) to a travel air and it didnt go very well. He struggled with the higher stall speed for quite some time. That said, we got there in the end.

Its a shame they dont make moonrakers any more as to me they were the best trainer ever made. Easy to fly, fully capable, only needed a small/cheap engine and would bite if you really really pushed it. It was also really strong.

Oh well

ChrisB08/11/2016 08:58:54
1220 forum posts
34 photos
Glad to hear your in contact with a club. I know of Tim and the Smithy MAC..you won't go far wrong with them!
The Wright Stuff08/11/2016 09:30:30
avatar
1394 forum posts
227 photos

I'd personally recommend the Speed Air over the Super Air, if you are transitioning into low wing IC. It's just that little bit more docile, and the ground handling is much nicer!

Cuban808/11/2016 09:55:27
3107 forum posts
1 photos

A chap I know had one of these **LINK**

as a first low winger. Rediculously easy to fly and nicely retro with a good pedigree.yes

They do an ARTF version as wellhttp://www.sussex-model-centre.co.uk/shopexd.asp?id=46302

Edited By Cuban8 on 08/11/2016 09:59:40

iqon08/11/2016 10:10:39
avatar
1506 forum posts
239 photos

Blackhorse renegade, for when you are ready.

Biggles' Elder Brother - Moderator08/11/2016 12:00:33
avatar
Moderator
15748 forum posts
1460 photos

The Boomerang is good - in fact its great - but its definitely a level up from the Apprentice - maybe two levels up!

Firstly it flys qute fast for trainer - its a fair weight.

Secondly it has a semi-symmetrical wing section - it's a lot more manoeuvrable (that's code for its a lot less stable!) than an Apprentice - even with the later on "Advanced".

That extra weight means you have a lot more inertia to manage. As others have said this requires a far more sophisticated flying technique - you have think ahead more, this won't "turn on sixpence" its wing loading is too high, if the Apprentice stalls its a complete non-event, it won't be viscous Boomerang (well not by warbird standards!) but it will definitely be "an event"!

So, I'm with the others - good start with the Apprentice and it will pay big dividends in enabling you to take the next steps quicker and earlier. But at this stage a low winger, especially with IC in that is also new to you, might just be a step too far - too many new things to master at the same time.

BEB

PS I'll have a informal wager with you - 6 months with IC and you'll be back on electric wondering why you left all that convenience and reliability behind!! I've seen it so many times!

Ian Mat08/11/2016 12:27:13
avatar
121 forum posts
39 photos

I learnt to fly on a tamed wot 4 and my next model was an acrowot, with a ASP52 engine. I found the Acrowot to be extremely forgiving and apart from the slightly more slippery shape, has a very similar flight envelope to the Wot4.

That would be my recommendation!

All Topics | Latest Posts

Please login to post a reply.

Latest Forum Posts
Support Our Partners
CML
Subscribe now
Sussex Model Centre
electricwingman 2017
Slec
Sarik
Advertise With Us
Latest "For Sale" Ads
NEW POLL - has the pandemic altered your event safety perceptions?
Q: Has the covid pandemic deterred you from attending shows and events in 2021?

 No, I'll be attending just as many as I usually do
 No, but I'll choose my event with greater care
 Yes, I'll attend fewer events going forward
 Yes, I wont attend any where previously I have

Latest Reviews
Digital Back Issues

RCM&E Digital Back Issues

Contact us

Contact us

Magazine Locator

Want the latest issue of RCM&E? Use our magazine locator link to find your nearest stockist!

Find RCM&E!